Jump to content

Pilot Capless Trapdoor Mechanisms


milo

Recommended Posts

Hi folks,

 

so I recently received a Blue Kasuri/Carbonesque which I purchased from a UK supplier. I was comparing the trapdoor mechanism with that of the Deep Yellow purchased from Japan. I swear they look different!

The yellow seems to have a vertical oriented spring that is compressed when the nib pushes through.

The blue seems to have a horizontal oriented spring attached to the underside of the hole, with a little rod that attaches to the trapdoor (the spring is similar to other spring based lever systems like clothes pegs or mouse traps).

 

Has anyone else noticed differences in mechanisms? Can anyone offer an explanation?

 

cheers,

Milo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 17
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • milo

    6

  • antoniosz

    4

  • Moose

    2

  • MYU

    2

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

  milo said:
Hi folks,

 

so I recently received a Blue Kasuri/Carbonesque which I purchased from a UK supplier. I was comparing the trapdoor mechanism with that of the Deep Yellow purchased from Japan. I swear they look different!

The yellow seems to have a vertical oriented spring that is compressed when the nib pushes through.

The blue seems to have a horizontal oriented spring attached to the underside of the hole, with a little rod that attaches to the trapdoor (the spring is similar to other spring based lever systems like clothes pegs or mouse traps).

 

Has anyone else noticed differences in mechanisms? Can anyone offer an explanation?

 

cheers,

Milo

 

No explanation here, but I just checked all six of my Vanishing Points and the Yellow and the Raden have the spring that looks like a 'W' with the middle flattened and coiled. The others (Black, Blue Kasuri, LE Orange, and Chrome) all have a spring which has the 'O' part touching the trap door ('O' as if you are looking "through" the spring. So I think mine are actually backwards from yours.

 

Okay, I did a horrible job explaining that. Suffice it to say: Yes, I have noticed a difference in the mechanisms. It may be due to a change in production as the Yellow and Raden are my two most recent purchases and it sounds like your Kasuri is your most recent. Maybe Pilot/Namiki changed the production on them!

Well for you, if you wrestle on, for in persistency lies victory, and with the morning may come the wished-for blessing. But not always; there is a struggle with defeat which some of you will have to bear, and it will be well for you if you have cultivated a cheerful equanimity. Remember, too, that sometimes 'from our desolation only does the better life begin.' Even with disaster ahead, it is better to face them with a smile, and with the head erect, than to crouch at their approach. And, if the fight is for principle and justice, even when failure seems certain, where many have failed before, cling to your ideal, and, like Childe Roland before the dark tower, set the slug-horn to your lips, blow the challenge, and calmly await the conflict.

 

 

--"Aequanimitas" William Osler

Valedictory Address, University of Pennsylvania, May 1, 1889

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The technical terms for the springs are "coil spring" or "compression spring" for the cylindrical ones and "torsion spring" for the W shaped one. I don't have an explanation for why they would be different but either type seems to be right for the application. Maybe Pilot swaps them in and out of the assembly line at will or maybe they changed from one type to the other at some point in time.

 

All my VPs, ranging from 2006 back to 1973 have the coil spring (including a Raden). The CL-200s and CL-300s from the 1960's have a leaf spring (a flat bar which provides the spring force). The "aluminum pipe" models from the 1960's use flat wire "leaf spring". The Sliding Clip model from 1968 has a "tension spring." All the VP designs seem to have some type of trap door but the spring has evolved...

 

By the way, Antoniosz once posted a cool x-ray shot of the trapdoor mechanism. I can't seem to find it but maybe somebody with better searching skills can.

 

/Woody

Edited by haywoody
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I look head on inside the mouth of the pens, this is pretty much what I see. On the left is the mechanism I have in the capless blue carbonesque which I received just over a week a go. The one on the right is the deep yellow from Japan which I received around June earlier this year.

 

post-11032-1230723618_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  haywoody said:
The technical terms for the springs are "coil spring" or "compression spring" for the cylindrical ones and "torsion spring" for the W shaped one. I don't have an explanation for why they would be different but either type seems to be right for the application. Maybe Pilot swaps them in and out of the assembly line at will or maybe they changed from one type to the other at some point in time.

/Woody

 

Thanks for the info, Haywoody! When I think about it, you perfectly described what I was trying to say.

 

As for the picture in your post, Milo, I have the exact opposite (your earlier yellow matches my earlier kasuri, your later kasuri matches my later yellow), so I am guessing Pilot switched their manufacturing at some point this year.

Well for you, if you wrestle on, for in persistency lies victory, and with the morning may come the wished-for blessing. But not always; there is a struggle with defeat which some of you will have to bear, and it will be well for you if you have cultivated a cheerful equanimity. Remember, too, that sometimes 'from our desolation only does the better life begin.' Even with disaster ahead, it is better to face them with a smile, and with the head erect, than to crouch at their approach. And, if the fight is for principle and justice, even when failure seems certain, where many have failed before, cling to your ideal, and, like Childe Roland before the dark tower, set the slug-horn to your lips, blow the challenge, and calmly await the conflict.

 

 

--"Aequanimitas" William Osler

Valedictory Address, University of Pennsylvania, May 1, 1889

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Haywoody's explanations are very useful...thank you Haywoody!

 

Looking at the two mechanisms, the more recent one seems to me to be more sturdy...hence at least in my opinion, an improvement in the already awesome design!

:thumbup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cools pics - I assume the top is a standard X-Ray. Is the second CT or MRI?

 

You're giving away your profession ;) My Dad is a radiologist.

 

PS, I'd love to see the whole pen like that!

Edited by Siv

http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2752/4371168844_35ba5fb338.jpg

Danitrio Fellow, Nakaya Nutter, Sailor Sailor (ret), Visconti Venerator, Montegrappa Molester (in training), ConwayStewart Champion & Diplomat #77

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Asolutely amazing!!!

Thank you so much for those images antoniosz. These demonstrate the mechanism in the older of the two pens I mentioned above.

 

cheers,

Milo

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  Siv said:
You're giving away your profession ;) My Dad is a radiologist.

PS, I'd love to see the whole pen like that!

It is a microCT that can reach a pixel size of about 1 micron.

Because of the resolution the specimen size has to be small and fit within a cylinder of 6cm dia and 6cm height, so I can not fit the whole pen :(

I am not a doctor or a radiologist :) :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So, a week a go I bought another Capless Kasuri, this time in black, to give to my PhD professor. This one had the spring as per antoniosz's photos (compression spring). My Blue one has the other type of spring. I would definitely be interested in learning more. Do you think Pilot UK might help me out?

 

cheers,

Milo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Wile E Coyote and I had fun this morning. He supplied the VPs and I supplied the x-rays.

 

2008LE

http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b325/azavalia/VP-xray/2008LE.jpg http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b325/azavalia/VP-xray/2008LE_0124.jpg

 

 

Fermo

http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b325/azavalia/VP-xray/Fermo.jpg http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b325/azavalia/VP-xray/Fermo_0117.jpg

 

Raden

http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b325/azavalia/VP-xray/Raden.jpg http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b325/azavalia/VP-xray/Raden_0078.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:notworthy1: Antoniosz...that is absolutely amazing. Your images show exactly what I was trying to explain before. Thank you so much for these. :thumbup:

cheers

Milo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Amazing radiographs Antonios! Which spring design seems to be more reliable? I think the torsion design will be more resistant to the spring getting dislodged. What do the experts think?

In case you wish to write to me, pls use ONLY email by clicking here. I do not check PMs. Thank you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Antonios, THANK YOU for these! Wow, what great detail--this is even better than the cut-away shots we got from Pilot Pen Station. How did you do this? Did you have to remove the nose-cone section of the VP, or were you able to do it fully assembled?

Edited by MYU

[MYU's Pen Review Corner] | "The Common Ground" -- Jeffrey Small

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I definitely appreciate not having to fully disassemble the pen. I thought that a partial tear down might be necessary for use with the equipment. But I'm glad that it was possible with the pen as-is.

 

As for design, I think the older coil spring design you see on the Raden is probably more reliable. You have a more even distribution of stress across the spring. But it means more metal. The newer design has a spring-lever type design. I could see over time a weakening taking place, as there is a lot of stress applied in one specific section of the spring. However, it is a cleaner design... I suspect the older design has a greater probability for attracting rust, as moisture gets trapped between the coils. Special forged stainless steel of sufficient thickness will simply not rust (as used on high quality knives), but for bendable metal I suspect that these springs are not completely impervious to rust.

Edited by MYU

[MYU's Pen Review Corner] | "The Common Ground" -- Jeffrey Small

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

 

The new design is harder to dislodge from the pen than the older type. I remember several people with the old type complaining that the spring popped out of their pen.

 

Dillon

Stolen: Aurora Optima Demonstrator Red ends Medium nib. Serial number 1216 and Aurora 98 Cartridge/Converter Black bark finish (Archivi Storici) with gold cap. Reward if found. Please contact me if you have seen these pens.

Please send vial orders and other messages to fpninkvials funny-round-mark-thing gmail strange-mark-thing com. My shop is open once again if you need help with your pen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Most Contributions

    1. amberleadavis
      amberleadavis
      43972
    2. PAKMAN
      PAKMAN
      34605
    3. inkstainedruth
      inkstainedruth
      28888
    4. Ghost Plane
      Ghost Plane
      28220
    5. Bo Bo Olson
      Bo Bo Olson
      27155
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Comments

  • Chatbox

    You don't have permission to chat.
    • Penguincollector 30 Mar 15:07
      Oh yes, pictures are on the “ I got this pen today” thread.
    • lectraplayer 29 Mar 9:19
      Is it here yet?
    • Penguincollector 26 Mar 5:00
      I just got the tracking information for my Starwalker💃🏻
    • T.D. Rabbit 3 Mar 12:46
      @lamarax I am horrified... And slightly intrigued. But mostly just scared.
    • lamarax 2 Mar 20:38
      Oh well. In case of failure you can always wring the paper to have a nice -albeit somewhat stale- cup of coffee back.
    • T.D. Rabbit 2 Mar 10:20
      @Astronymus I could use cornstarch... Or i could distill it and make it very concentrated.
    • T.D. Rabbit 2 Mar 10:20
      @lamarax That's what I used! (In reply to black coffee).. But the milk might not be good at all for paper.
    • Grayfeather 2 Mar 0:08
      Good day, all.
    • Gertrude F 20 Feb 17:58
      Sorry think I posted this in the wrong place. Used to be a user, just re-upped. Be kind. 😑
    • Gertrude F 20 Feb 17:56
      Looking to sell huge lot of pretty much every Man 200 made - FP, BP, MP, one or two RBs. Does anyone have a suggestion for a bulk purhase house? Thanks - and hope this doesn't violate any rules.
    • lamarax 17 Feb 18:05
      Cappuccino should work. Frothy milk also helps to lubricate the nib. But it has to be made by a barista.
    • Astronymus 17 Feb 16:19
      YOu might need to thicken the coffee with something. I admit I have no idea with what. But I'm pretty sure it would work.
    • asnailmailer 3 Feb 17:35
      it is incowrimo time and only very few people are tempting me
    • lamarax 31 Jan 21:34
      Try black coffee. No sugar.
    • T.D. Rabbit 31 Jan 8:11
      Coffee is too light to write with though I've tried.
    • Astronymus 29 Jan 21:46
      You can use coffee and all other kinds of fluid with a glas pen. 😉
    • Roger Zhao 29 Jan 14:37
      chocolate is yummy
    • Bucefalo 17 Jan 9:59
      anyone sells vacumatic push button shafts
    • stxrling 13 Jan 1:25
      Are there any threads or posts up yet about the California Pen Show in February, does anyone know?
    • lamarax 10 Jan 20:27
      Putting coffee in a fountain pen is far more dangerous
    • asnailmailer 9 Jan 0:09
      Don't drink the ink
    • zug zug Today 16:48
      Coffee inks or coffee, the drink? Both are yummy though.
    • LandyVlad Today 5:37
      I hear the price of coffee is going up. WHich is bad because I like coffee.
    • asnailmailer 6 Jan 14:43
      time for a nice cup of tea
    • Just J 25 Dec 1:57
      @liauyat re editing profile: At forum page top, find the Search panel. Just above that you should see your user name with a tiny down arrow [🔽] alongside. Click that & scroll down to CONTENT, & under that, Profile. Click that, & edit 'til thy heart's content!
    • liapuyat 12 Dec 12:20
      I can't seem to edit my profile, which is years out of date, because I've only returned to FPN again recently. How do you fix it?
    • mattaw 5 Dec 14:25
      @lantanagal did you do anything to fix that? I get that page every time I try to go to edit my profile...
    • Penguincollector 30 Nov 19:14
      Super excited to go check out the PDX Pen Bazaar today. I volunteered to help set up tables. It should be super fun, followed by Xmas tree shopping. 😁
    • niuben 30 Nov 10:41
      @Nurse Ratchet
    • Nurse Ratchet 30 Nov 2:49
      Newbie here!!! Helloall
    • Emes 25 Nov 23:31
      jew
    • Misfit 9 Nov 2:38
      lantanagal, I’ve only seen that happen when you put someone on the ignore list. I doubt a friend would do that.
    • lantanagal 7 Nov 19:01
      UPDATE - FIXED NOW Exact message is: Requested page not available! Dear Visitor of the Fountain Pen Nuthouse The page you are requesting to visit is not available to you. You are not authorised to access the requested page. Regards, The FPN Admin Team November 7, 2024
    • lantanagal 7 Nov 18:59
      UPDATE - FIXED NOW Trying to send a pen friend a reply to a message, keep getting an error message to say I don't have access. Anyone any ideas? (tried logging our and back in to no avail)
    • Dr.R 2 Nov 16:58
      Raina’s
    • fireant 2 Nov 1:36
      Fine-have you had a nibmeister look at it?
    • carlos.q 29 Oct 15:19
      @FineFinerFinest: have you seen this thread? https://www.fountainpennetwor...nging-pelikan-nibs/#comments
    • FineFinerFinest 24 Oct 8:52
      No replies required to my complaints about the Pelikan. A friend came to the rescue with some very magnification equipment - with the images thrown to a latge high res screen. Technology is a wonderful thing. Thanks to Mercian for the reply. I had been using the same paper & ink for sometime when the "singing" started. I have a theory but no proof that nibs get damaged when capping the pen. 👍
    • Mercian 22 Oct 22:28
      @FineFinerFinest: sometimes nib-'singing' can be lessened - or even cured - by changing the ink that one is putting through the pen, or the paper that one is using. N.b. *sometimes*. Good luck
    • Bluetaco 22 Oct 22:04
      howdy
    • FineFinerFinest 21 Oct 5:23
      I'm not expecting any replies to my question about the singing Pelikan nib. It seems, from reading the background, that I am not alone. It's a nice pen. It's such a pity Pelikan can't make decent nibs. I have occasionally met users who tell me how wonderful their Pelikan nib is. I've spent enough money to know that not everyone has this experience. I've worked on nibs occasionally over forty years with great success. This one has me beaten. I won't be buying any more Pelikan pens. 👎
    • FineFinerFinest 21 Oct 4:27
      I've had a Pelikan M805 for a couple of years now and cannot get the nib to write without singing. I've worked on dozens of nibs with great success. Ny suggestion about what's going wrong? 😑
    • Bhakt 12 Oct 5:45
      Any feedback in 100th anniversary Mont Blanc green pens?
    • Glens pens 8 Oct 15:08
      @jordierocks94 i happen to have platinum preppy that has wrote like (bleep) since i bought it my second pen....is that something you would wish to practice on?
    • jordierocks94 4 Oct 6:26
      Hello all - New here. My Art studies have spilled me into the ft pen world where I am happily submerged and floating! I'm looking to repair some cheap pens that are starving for ink yet filled, and eventually get new nibs; and development of repair skills (an even longer learning curve than my art studies - lol). Every hobby needs a hobby, eh ...
    • The_Beginner 18 Sept 23:35
      horse notebooks if you search the title should still appear though it wont show you in your proflie
    • Jayme Brener 16 Sept 22:21
      Hi, guys. I wonder if somebody knows who manufactured the Coro fountain pens.
    • TheHorseNotebooks 16 Sept 13:11
      Hello, it's been ages for me since I was here last time. I had a post (http://www.fountainpennetwork...-notebooks/?view=getnewpost) but I see that it is no longer accessible. Is there anyway to retrieve that one?
    • Refujio Rodriguez 16 Sept 5:39
      I have a match stick simplomatic with a weidlich nib. Does anyone know anything about this pen?
    • The_Beginner 15 Sept 16:11
      dusty yes, glen welcome
    • Glens pens 11 Sept 1:22
      Hello, Im new to FPN I'm so happy to find other foutain penattics. collecting almost one year ,thought I would say hello to everyone.
    • DustyBin 8 Sept 14:34
      I haven't been here for ages... do I take it that private sales are no longer allowed? Also used to be a great place to sell and buy some great pens
    • Sailor Kenshin 1 Sept 12:37
      Lol…
    • JungleJim 1 Sept 1:55
      Perhaps it's like saying Beetlejuice 3 times to get that person to appear, though with @Sailor Kenshin you only have to say it twice?
    • Sailor Kenshin 31 Aug 21:06
      ?
    • Duffy 29 Aug 19:31
      @Sailor Kenshin @Sailor Kenshin
    • Seney724 26 Aug 22:07
    • Diablo 26 Aug 22:05
      Thank you so much, Seney724. I really appreciate your help!
    • Seney724 26 Aug 21:43
      I have no ties or relationship. Just a very happy customer. He is a very experienced Montblanc expert.
    • Seney724 26 Aug 21:42
      I strongly recommend Kirk Speer at https://www.penrealm.com/
    • Diablo 26 Aug 21:35
      @Seney724. The pen was recently disassembled and cleaned, but the nib and feed were not properly inserted into the holder. I'm in Maryland.
    • Diablo 26 Aug 21:32
      @Seney724. The nib section needs to be adjusted properly.
    • Seney724 26 Aug 18:16
      @Diablo. Where are you? What does it need?
    • Diablo 26 Aug 16:58
      Seeking EXPERIENCED, REPUTABLE service/repair for my 149. PLEASE help!!!
    • Penguincollector 19 Aug 19:42
      @Marta Val, reach out to @terim, who runs Peyton Street Pens and is very knowledgeable about Sheaffer pens
    • Marta Val 19 Aug 14:35
      Hello, could someone recommend a reliable venue: on line or brick and mortar in Fairfax, VA or Long Island, NY to purchase the soft parts and a converter to restore my dad's Sheaffer Legacy? please. Thanks a mill.
    • The_Beginner 18 Aug 2:49
      is there a guy who we can message to find a part for us with a given timelimit if so please let me know his name!
    • virtuoso 16 Aug 15:15
      what happene to the new Shaeffer inks?
    • Scribs 14 Aug 17:09
      fatehbajwa, in Writing Instruments, "Fountain Pens + Dip Pens First Stop" ?
    • fatehbajwa 14 Aug 12:17
      Back to FPN after 14 years. First thing I noticed is that I could not see a FS forum. What has changed? 🤔
    • Kika 5 Aug 10:22
      Are there any fountain pen collectors in Qatar?
    • T.D. Rabbit 31 July 18:58
      Ahh okay, thanks!
    • Scribs 29 July 18:51
      @ TDRabbit, even better would be in Creative Expressions area, subform The Write Stuff
    • T.D. Rabbit 29 July 11:40
      Okay, thanks!
    • JungleJim 29 July 0:46
      @T.D. Rabbit Try posting it in the "Chatter Forum". You have to be logged in to see it.
    • T.D. Rabbit 28 July 17:54
      Hello! Is there a thread anywhere 'round here where one can post self-composed poetry? If not, would it be alright if I made one? I searched on google, but to no avail...
    • OldFatDog 26 July 19:41
      I have several Parker Roller Ball & Fiber Tip refills in the original packaging. Where and how do I sell them? The couple that I've opened the ink still flowed when put to paper. Also if a pen would take the foller ball refill then it should take the fiber tip as well? Anyway it's been awhile and I'm want to take my message collection beyond the few pieces that I have... Meaning I don't have a Parker these refills will fit in 🙄
    • RegDiggins 23 July 12:40
      Recently was lucky enough to buy a pristine example of the CF crocodile ball with the gold plating. Then of course I faced the same problem we all have over the years ,of trying to find e refill. Fortunately I discovered one here in the U.K. I wonder if there are other sources which exist in other countries, by the way they were not cheap pen
    • The_Beginner 20 July 20:35
      Hows it going guys i have a code from pen chalet that i wont use for 10% off and it ends aug 31st RC10AUG its 10% off have at it fellas
    • T.D. Rabbit 19 July 9:33
      Somewhat confusing and off-putting ones, as said to me by my very honest friends. I don't have an X account though :<
    • piano 19 July 8:41
      @The Devil Rabbit what kind of? Let’s go to X (twitter) with #inkdoodle #inkdoodleFP
    • Mort639 17 July 1:03
      I have a Conway Stewart Trafalgar set. It was previously owned by actor Russell Crowe and includes a letter from him. Can anyone help me with assessing its value?
    • Sailor Kenshin 15 July 17:41
      There must be a couple of places here to share artworks.
    • T.D. Rabbit 15 July 12:45
      Hullo! I really like making ink doodles, and I'd like to share a few. Anywhere on the site I can do so? Thanks in advance!
    • Sailor Kenshin 6 July 17:58
      Pay It Forward.
    • AndWhoDisguisedAs 6 July 16:59
      where would I post wanting to trade bottle of ink straight up?
    • JungleJim 3 July 16:14
      @Bill Wood-- just look at the message below you that was posted by @PAKMAN. He is a moderator here on the forums.
    • Bill Wood 2 July 14:24
      Just checking on a classified section and where we are with that. Many thanks. Bill
    • PAKMAN 29 June 1:57
      @inky1 The software for the classified stopped working with the forum. So no we don't have a sales section anymore at FPN
    • inky1 28 June 16:49
      I am not sure which is the classifieds section
    • inky1 28 June 16:46
      IIs there a Fountain Pen Sales board anywhere on here?
    • dave c 25 June 19:01
      Hi. Anybody ever heard about a Royal Puck Pen. Very small but good looking.
    • Eppie_Matts 23 June 19:25
      Thanks! I've just ordered some #6's to experiment with.
    • Al-fresco 21 June 12:11
      @Eppie_Matts Shouldn't be a problem - I've just put a Bock #6 Titanium into a La Grande Bellezza section. Went straight in without any problem.
    • Curiousone11 21 June 4:35
      Any recommendations on anyone who specializes in original pen patents?
    • Eppie_Matts 20 June 1:32
      Hi all - I'm new to experimenting with pens and nibs. Can I put a bock 6 on a Pineider? Thanks!
    • penned in 16 June 17:33
      Hi, I'm new to this forum and was wondering where is the best place to sell a Montblanc ballpoint pen? Are ballpoints allowed here? It's a beautiful pen that deserves a great listing. Thanks.
    • ChrisUrbane 9 June 3:16
      I havent logged in here for a while. I have moved and when I try to change my location on my profile, when I go to save it, it sais 'page not found' and that I do not have authority to change that.
    • Dlj 6 June 20:19
      I am looking for someone who can repair a Waterman Preface ballpoint that won’t stay together
    • Penguincollector 30 May 14:59
      I just noticed that the oppsing team of the game I watched last night had a player named Biro in their lineup. He must be part of Marsell the oily magician’s cadre
    Load More
  • Files






×
×
  • Create New...