Jump to content

Q: I Use Western Fine Nibs. What Is The Japanese Equivalent?


A Smug Dill

Recommended Posts

  On 2/12/2019 at 7:02 AM, cattar said:

The question is do you want that nib, or would you rather having something else for the same amount?

In the end, neither.

 

I saw a new Sailor Profit Black Luster with a ruthenium-plated 21K gold F nib – which is identical to the nib on my Sailor Professional Gear Imperial Black – being listed for ¥22,000 (tax-inclusive), which works out to US$199. There is the option of an EF nib, but it brings the price up to ¥25,000. I was of two minds as to whether to pay the 13.6% premium, since an EF nib was (and is) not an available option for the PG-IB pen, and I have pulled the nib and feed out of the latter's section before for a thorough cleaning, so I know I could swap nibs of different width grades between those pens at will (which I'm sure would be considered as voiding warranty).

 

But then, I thought, the key question is whether the F nib is fine enough for my purpose, and not how to get the most flexibility out of the deal to include options of which I have no use, or to get as fine a nib as the manufacturer has to offer 'just because' I can. Inked with Diamine Deep Dark Blue, which I don't believe has the same reputation for 'taming' wet nibs and coaxing narrower lines out of them, with no trouble at all I can draw 11 – and, if I really tried, 12 – parallel horizontal lines distinctly inside a 5mm square, and that's using the nib in normal orientation, without flipping it upside down to get narrower lines (which I can do with that nib). I only need to be able to draw 9 such lines inside the em-square to write in Chinese legibly, so the F nib is already fine enough and then some. Now that I've learnt from experience that there is such a thing as too fine, I guess buying two gold Sailor EF nibs is just taking things ridiculously far, when I got by for so long just using the Sailor 1911 F and MF nibs I have; and thus the urge has dissolved.

 

So I pulled the trigger and bought the Sailor Profit Black Luster with the F nib instead.

 

  On 2/12/2019 at 4:27 PM, Lamyliz said:

Thanks asmugdill, don't worry I think I'm sorted now. Just curious why you don't seem to like the capless?

Huh? I love the Pilot Capless pens, and we have twelve in our household. All seven of mine are in the Vanishing Point line, whereas my fiancée has a mix of VP and Decimo pens.

 

The step in line widths between Pilot Capless F and M nibs is typically bigger than that between (say) Pilot Custom 74 F and M nibs, that's what others meant in those reviews and comments you read elsewhere. Especially if people are moving 'up' to Pilot Capless from steel-nibbed Pilot models – try comparing:

  • Pilot Decimo (or Vanishing Point) F nib
  • Pilot Decimo M nib
  • Pilot Prera (or Metropolitan) M nib
  • Pilot Prera F nib
and you'll see why being find the Pilot Capless M nib to be such a surprise. Edited by A Smug Dill

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 50
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • A Smug Dill

    22

  • shawnee

    15

  • cattar

    5

  • Lamyliz

    3

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

I'm going to try to squeeze it all into one post, bear with me:

 

>>Interesting. I think the Pilot MR nibs are on the wet side (although I almost never use the single M nib of that type I have, so my comment really applies only to the F nibs), but considering that you have more than one Pelikan pen, I imagined the Pilot MR is no match for those in the ink flow department.

>>My one and only Pelikan has a customised nib, so it certainly doesn't write overly wetly. However, I'm not really looking forward to experiencing three factory-condition Pelikan F nibs on pens that are on their way to me in the post.

 

I actually only have one Pelikan, a Souveran M600, and it's likely to be my last. It has an 'M' nib which is completely unusable for me and there is an 'EF' nib on its way from the Netherlands. I wasn't overly thrilled to have to purchase *another* nib since the US distributor wouldn't honor a nib exchange given the fact that the pen came from Europe, but even with the nib exchange, I'll end up still spending about the same if I'd bought the pen from a US vendor. The Pilot MR isn't nearly as wet, you're right, smugdill, thankfully. I went back and used it again this morning and I'm getting used to it, but it's still heavy and this is weird, but it's the only pen where my fingertips sweat from holding it. My hand gets clammy. It's the first time that has happened to me. It's a bit icky. LOL. I want to like Pilot. I just have to find a better entry point.

 

 

>>I prefer Sailor's nibs, then Platinum's variety of nib experiences, then Pilot's steel nibs or the gold falcon nib. The other Pilot gold nibs are too smooth.

 

Cattar, I know above you said that you liked the "pencilly" feel of the Sailor nibs - are you talking gold nibs or steel nibs? Or just the nib feel overall for Sailor? I actually have three Sailors coming as of right now: a used 1911M with a 'h-f' nib, a Sailor Shikori Fountain Pen with an 'MF' nib, and I lacked impulse control and got the Procolor 500 with an 'F' nib because it was only $40. I'm all over the map, I know. That with the 'soft fine' Platinum 3776 is going to have to keep me occupied for now EXCEPT that my dad wants to buy me a birthday gift (around the $50 range) and so I'm trying to find a Japanese pen that's worth trying out in that price range. It sounds like maybe a Platinum Balance could work and I like the idea of playing around with the Pilot Plumix pens, but are there any other Pilots in the $50 range that are worth trying other than the Pilot MR? It seems to jump up significantly after that when you get to Custom 74s and the Heritage 91s.

 

Is there significant difference between the Sailor 1911 standard and 1911M other than size? I know the nib is wider on the standard and comes in 21K, but is it like a huge jump in body size like there is between the MB146 and MB149? The MB149 is waaaaay too big for me. I like the size of the Platinum 3776 and I'm also okay with a slimmer pen, but seriously fat pens are too fatiguing for me personally. Also, yes, I need to go to a pen show where most of these questions would be answered. I know, I know. LOL

 

Lamyliz - the Goulet chart helped me a lot. I think it works pretty well.

 

 

shawnee

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/7/2019 at 2:35 AM, A Smug Dill said:

I understand that forming each letter of the English letter alphabet with a single pen stroke, much less joining letters to form an entire word in cursive, is not the only way to hand-write in English, irrespective of what they teach in schools in the UK and the US.

 

 

Sorry for the aside here, but I'm not sure I understand the comment, and curiosity is getting the best of me, so I have to ask: is it your understanding that cursive is taught in schools in the US?

 

If so, I'd like to offer my observations on that: currently, "cursive", in general, is not taught in most US public schools (there might be exceptions; I don't have extensive knowledge of the full curriculum taught at all schools across the USA) and in some cases, even basic "handwriting" is skipped over completely in the youngest grades (Kindergarten, First & Second grades). For some private schools, the general "handwriting" courses will have an introduction to a form of cursive, but which one is up to the school. My wife is a teacher and principal of a small private school and they used to teach a version of the Palmer method starting in 3rd or 4th grade. The teacher of that class used actual fountain pens too! The kids had to turn the pen in at the end of class (shame they didn't get to keep them -- might help to spread the love of Fps!). She has since retired and I'm not sure handwriting is currently being taught. I'll have to follow up with my wife on that. My wife has, however, verified that most public schools throughout Texas do not bother with cursive, and in most cases, handwriting at all. Many schools are moving towards iPads with customized software for teaching instead of having the kids write anything down on paper. Tests are taken electronically, etc. It bothers me a bit, but my preferences for a kid learning to write, and do it well -- with cursive -- can extend only as far as my own children. What the rest of the world does is up to them after all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/12/2019 at 5:42 PM, sirgilbert357 said:

Sorry for the aside here, but I'm not sure I understand the comment, and curiosity is getting the best of me, so I have to ask: is it your understanding that cursive is taught in schools in the US?

 

I don't know the first thing about what is or isn't taught in schools in the US. The gist of my comment was that so many people here seem to frame handwriting (in English, and with fountain pens) around the presupposition that cursive is the only, or proper, way to write, and thus excluding 'printing' and hands such as Italic from the scope of normal or common handwriting. That cannot be correct, irrespective of what is or isn't taught; I don't believe cursive is the only way of writing that is taught and/or deemed acceptable in the UK and the US.

 

  On 2/12/2019 at 5:15 PM, shawnee said:

I actually only have one Pelikan, a Souveran M600,

 

I thought you had a Pelikan P205 as well. My miscomprehension.

 

  Quote

I wasn't overly thrilled to have to purchase *another* nib

 

I wouldn't be, either.

 

  Quote

... I'm getting used to [the Pilot MR], but it's still heavy and this is weird, but it's the only pen where my fingertips sweat from holding it.

...‹snip›...

... my dad wants to buy me a birthday gift (around the $50 range) and so I'm trying to find a Japanese pen that's worth trying out in that price range. It sounds like maybe a Platinum Balance could work and I like the idea of playing around with the Pilot Plumix pens, but are there any other Pilots in the $50 range that are worth trying other than the Pilot MR? It seems to jump up significantly after that when you get to Custom 74s and the Heritage 91s.

 

There's the Prera, which uses the same type of nib and feed as the Pilot MR, so any difference in the writing experience would only be due to the pen body. If you don't like the weight, balance, shape and/or texture of the MR, I suppose you could try a Prera. Or perhaps the new Pilot Explorer, about which I personally don't know anything, other than that its street price in the US is about US$24 each. Or maybe a Pilot Lucina?

 

  Quote

Is there significant difference between the Sailor 1911 standard and 1911M other than size? I know the nib is wider on the standard and comes in 21K, but is it like a huge jump in body size like there is between the MB146 and MB149?

I don't know anything about the Montblanc models and am not going to look them up, sorry.

 

Measurements of the Sailor 1911 Standard (taking the 11-1219* model for example) are: 17mm (max) diameter, 135mm long, weighs 17.0g

Measurements of the Sailor 1911 Large (taking the 11-2021* model for example) are: 18mm (max) diameter, 141mm long, weighs 21.6g

 

Which Shikiori and Procolor 500 models did you get? Were you talking about a steel-nibbed Shikiori, or a gold-nibbed Professional Gear Slim Shikiori?

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/12/2019 at 6:21 PM, A Smug Dill said:

 

I don't know the first thing about what is or isn't taught in schools in the US. The gist of my comment was that so many people here seem to frame handwriting (in English, and with fountain pens) around the presupposition that cursive is the only, or proper, way to write, and thus excluding 'printing' and hands such as Italic from the scope of normal or common handwriting. That cannot be correct, irrespective of what is or isn't taught; I don't believe cursive is the only way of writing that is taught and/or deemed acceptable in the UK and the US.

 

 

Ah, OK. Yes, the forum certainly has a bias in that regard. I can write in cursive and a form of print that I just kind of fell into (all caps - it drives my wife nuts, lol!), but I would love to learn many others. I don't think the world outside of FPN really cares or has a certain "standard". Handwriting, in general, just isn't used that much anymore...sadly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/12/2019 at 6:35 PM, sirgilbert357 said:

 

Ah, OK. Yes, the forum certainly has a bias in that regard. I can write in cursive and a form of print that I just kind of fell into (all caps - it drives my wife nuts, lol!), but I would love to learn many others. I don't think the world outside of FPN really cares or has a certain "standard". Handwriting, in general, just isn't used that much anymore...sadly.

 

SirGilbert - same on my end as well including the caps. Cursive writing is a dying art form unfortunately. There is some crazy statistic running around about how few millenials can write in cursive and not even a signature. Everything is done electronically these days. End of times, I say! Let me see if I can find the statistic and article . . .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You're right, smugdill. I *had* a P205 with a 'F' nib that I returned due to scratchiness. It was a steel nib so I'm hoping that I'm not the complete idiot who just ordered the 'EF' only to find it worse. That could be me, I'm not going to lie.

>>I don't know anything about the Montblanc models and am not going to look them up, sorry.

Wait, you don't offer full service feedback? I didn't see that anywhere in the fine print!

>>Measurements of the Sailor 1911 Standard (taking the 11-1219* model for example) are: 17mm (max) diameter, 135mm long, weighs 17.0g
>>Measurements of the Sailor 1911 Large (taking the 11-2021* model for example) are: 18mm (max) diameter, 141mm long, weighs 21.6g

So don't yell at me, but I want to make sure I have this right. There are 3 sizes whether you're talking 1911 or progear: standard (also called mid-sized and designated with an 'M' in the US), large and then King of pen size, right?


>>Which Shikiori and Procolor 500 models did you get? Were you talking about a steel-nibbed Shikiori, or a gold-nibbed Professional Gear Slim Shikiori?

So I got the procolor 500 Uchimizu 'Transparent Blue' in a 'F' nib (It was only $40 and an impulse purchase) and SAILOR Professional Gear Shiki-Oriori Four Season Edition Haruzora with an 'MF' nib. Pen-pen Avenue had it for less than $100 USD, but it went out of stock. When it came back in stock, I wasn't going to let it go a second time. Hopefully, it'll show up.

That have the 302, which is green in stock, for just a few dollars more, but I wanted the sky blue one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/12/2019 at 7:23 PM, shawnee said:
There are 3 sizes whether you're talking 1911 or progear: standard (also called mid-sized and designated with an 'M' in the US), large and then King of pen size, right?
Size
Product Family
Profit (aka 1911, in the West)
Professional Gear
Mid-size
Profit (aka 1911 Standard)
Professional Gear Slim
Full-size
Profit21 (aka 1911 Large),Profit REALO (aka 1911 REALO)
Professional Gear,Professional Gear REALO
Oversize
King of Pens(KOP ST, KOP Ebonite,KOP Briar, KOP Urushi, etc.)
Professional Gear KOP
 
  Quote
I got the procolor 500 Uchimizu 'Transparent Blue' in a 'F' nib (It was only $40 and an impulse purchase) and SAILOR Professional Gear Shiki-Oriori Four Season Edition Haruzora with an 'MF' nib.
Nice! Edited by A Smug Dill

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So 1911M is “midsize” or standard. The lack of standardized naming conventions across the brand line is highly confusing I have to say. I know it’s because of different markets, but still confusing for a newbie like me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/12/2019 at 4:39 PM, A Smug Dill said:

I saw a new Sailor Profit Black Luster with a ruthenium-plated 21K gold F nib – which is identical to the nib on my Sailor Professional Gear Imperial Black – being listed for ¥22,000 (tax-inclusive), which works out to US$199.

...‹snip›...

So I pulled the trigger and bought the Sailor Profit Black Luster with the F nib instead.

 

The price dropped by just over 10% in less than 12 hours after I placed the order, but when I tried to cancel it (prior to receiving a dispatch notification), I was advised that it was too late in the process and I have to do the whole returns thing.

:gaah:

It took a couple of international calls (and I don't speak Japanese!) to get that resolved, after the parcel courier service collected (or is that received?) and scanned the parcel, and I had a tracking number as reference. Hopefully it's all good now, although I now have another significant charge against my credit card while the original order is getting sorted out by Amazon.

 

There are nine eight eleven more units of this pen (with F and M nibs) available – sold and fulfilled by Amazon.co.jp – when I looked half an hour ago just now.

Edited by A Smug Dill

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Man, I hate when price drops happen and that’s a good price on that pen if it’s the one called Imperial Black in the US.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Imperial Black is actually a full-size Sailor Professional Gear with a (what other manufacturers, such as Aurora, would call) satin black resin body, which is not glossy and highly polished like the finish on the Sailor Profit Black Luster.

 

Both of those pens have the same recommended retail price (at least in Japan).

 

I've had my Pro Gear Imperial Black for almost five years now. Great pen with which to write, although I'm not sure it's 'worth' the price; but then, it's still cheaper than, say, an Aurora Talentum Full Black which has the same sort of 'stealth' look.

Edited by A Smug Dill

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On a side note, the Sailor Procolor 500 arrived and I LOVES IT. MY PRECIOUSSSsSssS.

 

Seriously, I shouldve started with Sailor. I love the pencilly feedback and the F nib is just about the right line size for me. Is it worth getting a promenade or go straight to the 1911s?

post-121617-0-71388900-1550231604_thumb.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nice handwriting!

 

  On 2/15/2019 at 11:55 AM, shawnee said:

I love the pencilly feedback and the F nib is just about the right line size for me.

I'm glad to hear that! I hope and trust you'll also find the 18K gold MF nib agreeable.

 

  Quote

Is it worth getting a promenade or go straight to the 1911s?

That depends on what you're looking for in a pen, especially if it's something that the Pro Gear Slim Shikiori you've already ordered won't give you:

Product lineMax diameterLength

(capped)

WeightNib(s)
Pro Gear Slim Shikiori17.4mm124mm16.8g14K gold, medium-sized, MF only
Pro Gear Slim17mm124mm16.8g14K gold, medium-sized,

F, M or B

Promenade17.4mm136.7mm18.2g14K gold, medium-sized,

EF, F, MF, M or B

Profit (aka 1911) Standard17mm135mm17.0g14K or 21K gold, medium-sized,

EF, F, MF, M, B, Zoom or Music

Profit21 (aka 1911 Large)18mm141mm21.6g21K gold, medium-sized,

EF, F, MF, M, B, Zoom or Music

Professional Gear18mm129mm21.6g21K gold, medium-sized,

F, M or B

 

Personally I'd recommend looking further afield. If you're in a, "Oh, I love Sailor pens, I want to acquire more of them!" phase, then perhaps look at some of the more interesting finishes such as the Precious Woods line (I had one, but the barrel is too slender for my tastes, in spite of the pen body being nominally thicker than even the Promenade) or the koshu-inden models (which I love but you probably won't because they're hefty).

 

Better yet, I'd say try something else, if you're still exploring. Perhaps an Aurora Ipsilon (with steel nib) or Ipsilon Deluxe (with 14K gold nib). A month ago I could have bought an Ipsilon Deluxe for A$160 delivered to Australia (when combined with something else on the same order), and that's less than the price of Sailor Profit21.

 

Just now I went and wrote with a whole bunch of different pens (to decide whether I'm really so keen on completing my collection of Platinum #3776 briar pens, actually, while I'm getting together a shipment of products to be forwarded to me using a Japanese reshipper), and my Pilot Custom Kaede (Maple)'s 14K gold #10 F nib offered the closest nib-on-paper feel (as well as line width, which of course is ink dependent) to the Sailor ruthenium-plated 21K gold F nib. It has essentially the same form factor as the Pilot Custom 74 (of which I have two, and I don't like them), and the wooden barrel feels great to the touch and is not heavy at all at 17g (then add 4g for a filled CON-70 converter). It (as well as the 21K gold Sailor F nib) offers slightly less 'pencilly' feedback than the 14K gold MF nib on my Sailor koshu-inden, but there is definitely feedback nevertheless, enough to give me precise control when writing. You could probably find one of those at US$160–$170 shipped. Probably worth considering as an alternative to a Sailor 1911 Standard.

Edited by A Smug Dill

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the further suggestions SmugDill - I'm looking at the Aurora now.

 

I'm using the Sailor 1911M with a F nib and interestingly, I'm not as keen on it as the Sailor Pro Color 500 with the steel 'F' nib, which seemed counter-intuitive to me since I'm not a fan of steel nibs. I have to say that the Pro Color is my pen of choice right now over everything else, which sort of cracks me up since it cost like $40 USD. Don't judge a pen by it's price tag.

 

I'll attach a writing sample later, and the SAILOR Professional Gear Shiki-Oriori Four Season Edition Haruzora with an 'MF' nib showed up yesterday as well. I haven't inked it yet, but was surprised about how much shorter it is because it doesn't have the cigar ends of the 1911. Every day is like an education in this place.

 

shawnee

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I haven't actually used an Aurora Ipsilon (with either steel or gold nib) myself, but I'm very happy with the Aurora Optima 365, two Aurora 88, and the Aurora Talentum I have. The Aurora Alpha isn't bad, either, but mine's 14K gold EF nib writes a bit broader than I like (and broader than the 18K gold EF nibs on the Optima and the 88s. I'm very wary of 'Western' fountain pen brands these days in general, but Aurora is the frontrunner if I'm considering spending (a significant amount of) money on one. Not so Pelikan! Even the relative newcomer brand Leonardo beats Pelikan in my book, steel nib against steel nib or even steel nib (of the former) against gold nib (of the latter), and I think that's a little sad.

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/21/2019 at 1:23 PM, A Smug Dill said:

I haven't actually used an Aurora Ipsilon (with either steel or gold nib) myself, but I'm very happy with the Aurora Optima 365, two Aurora 88, and the Aurora Talentum I have. The Aurora Alpha isn't bad, either, but mine's 14K gold EF nib writes a bit broader than I like (and broader than the 18K gold EF nibs on the Optima and the 88s. I'm very wary of 'Western' fountain pen brands these days in general, but Aurora is the frontrunner if I'm considering spending (a significant amount of) money on one. Not so Pelikan! Even the relative newcomer brand Leonardo beats Pelikan in my book, steel nib against steel nib or even steel nib (of the former) against gold nib (of the latter), and I think that's a little sad.

 

Having just looked at pricing, I might have to save up. Holy Macaroni. LOL. The Ipsilon is probably the only one within range right now. BUT . . . I have just bought a bunch of used Pilots, Platinums, and Sailors from Japan so I'm hoping that the US Postal Service is gentle and actually delivers them in the next four weeks.

 

My brand new Platinum 3776 with the 'soft nib' showed up with what I'm calling a bent 'ski slope' nib so I'm waiting for the vendor to get back to me. I feel like I return more pens than purchase at the moment.

 

I've got the Sailor Haruzora, 2 Plaisirs, and 2 Parkers to test. And my favorite . . . a $5 Daiso Japan 'Rosso Bianco' fountain pen that I picked up in Japantown in SF last Christmas. I wish I'd picked one up in every color.

 

But I'm keeping my eye on Aurora when my next royalties come in! Plus, I'm going to need some grinds on my MBs 146s. I should've picked a cheaper hobby.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have just received six fountain pens (one ordered as far back as last November, and one ordered just ten days ago, and then several in between) this week, and I ordered fourteen (mostly Sailor) pens from Japan yet to be packed into a single shipment for the reshipper to forward to me. I must've lost my marbles.

 

For now, the pen that must have its nib ground at the first reasonable opportunity is the 18K gold F nib on my new Pelikan M815. Compared to the steel EF nib on my Leonardo Momento Zero, which I already think writes too broadly to test my tolerance, the LMZ's nib is a joy to use. Right now the only way I can remotely enjoy using the M815 is by reverse-writing with the nib upside-down.

Edited by A Smug Dill

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/22/2019 at 2:35 AM, A Smug Dill said:

I have just received six fountain pens (one ordered as far back as last November, and one ordered just ten days ago, and then several in between) this week, and I ordered fourteen (mostly Sailor) pens from Japan yet to be packed into a single shipment for the reshipper to forward to me. I must've lost my marbles.

 

For now, the pen that must have its nib ground at the first reasonable opportunity is the 18K gold F nib on my new Pelikan M815. Compared to the steel EF nib on my Leonardo Momento Zero, which I already think writes too broadly to test my tolerance, the LMZ's nib is a joy to use. Right now the only way I can remotely enjoy using the M815 is by reverse-writing with the nib upside-down.

 

I'm sorry, but aren't you the person who told me NOT to focus all my attention on buying Sailor fountain pens? What fourteen pens did you order?

 

Also, I feel your pain on Pelikan. I'm still waiting for my 'EF' nib from La Couronne du Comte for my M600. I think it's my first and last Pelikan purchase if I was to be honest. If I could sell my MB 146s and not make a loss, I'd probably do that, too.

 

Are you able to find a nibmeister in Australia or do you have to send the Pelikan overseas? I can't get over that you have to have a reshipper for all your pens. It seems like such a hassle.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  On 2/22/2019 at 2:42 AM, shawnee said:

I'm sorry, but aren't you the person who told me NOT to focus all my attention on buying Sailor fountain pens? What fourteen pens did you order?

  • 1x Sailor Profit (1911 Large) Black Luster with ruthenium-plated 21K gold F nib

    (I already have the Sailor Pro Gear Imperial Black with the same nib, and I like it)

  • 1x Sailor Promenade in black with 14K gold EF nib

    (cheapest pen with a gold EF nib in the 1911 line, just to test out Sailor's EF nibs for myself)

  • 2x Sailor ProColor 500 (uchimizu, and stardust)

    (This is where I've lost my mind. I don't need to test how the steel 1911-inscribed nibs compare against Sailor's gold nibs. I blame you!)

  • 6x Sailor Profit Junior demonstrators in various colours, all with MF nibs
  • (as ink 'tester' pens or possibly random/Christmas gifts – I have three specially engraved Sailor Lecoule pens, which use the same nibs and feeds, and they're OK)
  • 1x Sailor desk pen with a steel EF nib

    (to replace the two I have ruined by trying to smooth out the awfully scratchy nibs – and by that I mean they were physically ripping up the coating/surface on the Rhodia paper I normally use, just with my regular very light hand when I write in Chinese. Third time lucky?)

  • 1x Pilot ELABO (aka Falcon) with a metal barrel and soft Extra Fine nib

    (cheaper than I can get the 'resin' barrel version of same on either Amazon or eBay)

Ah, and as I've stated elsewhere, I just cannot bloody count. The spreadsheet told me there were 14 entries with 'pen' in the shipment, but two of them are actually Sailor leather pen cases to hold five pens each. I already have one of those, that I ordered from Singapore last year at nearly double the price (but still a good price, compared to other brand-name leather pen cases of that capacity).

 

As for not just focussing on Sailor, I can assure you that Sailor pens are a minority in my personal 'fleet' or 'collection' of fountain pens, even when I take these into account. :blush:

 

  Quote

Are you able to find a nibmeister in Australia or do you have to send the Pelikan overseas?

 

Not that I'm aware. There's going to be a Sydney Pen Show in August, and I'm hoping there might be someone there who can do the job. Otherwise I might sell it (unlikely), or eventually give it away to someone in my extended family or social circle who is less picky about pens (but 'deserve' a A$600 gift for the occasion).

I endeavour to be frank and truthful in what I write, show or otherwise present, when I relate my first-hand experiences that are not independently verifiable; and link to third-party content where I can, when I make a claim or refute a statement of fact in a thread. If there is something you can verify for yourself, I entreat you to do so, and judge for yourself what is right, correct, and valid. I may be wrong, and my position or say-so is no more authoritative and carries no more weight than anyone else's here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Most Contributions

    1. amberleadavis
      amberleadavis
      43972
    2. PAKMAN
      PAKMAN
      34631
    3. inkstainedruth
      inkstainedruth
      28923
    4. Ghost Plane
      Ghost Plane
      28220
    5. Bo Bo Olson
      Bo Bo Olson
      27179
  • Upcoming Events

  • Blog Comments

  • Chatbox

    You don't have permission to chat.
    • Jeffrey Sher Today 12:00
      CANNOT FIND A LINK to pen club israel. what is eth website please
    • Penguincollector 15 Apr 22:48
      @bhavini, I really like the Sailor Hocoro dip pen. It’s inexpensive, easy to clean, and if you get one with a nib that has a feed, you can get quite a few lines of writing before you have to dip again. I have a fude nib, which I use for swatching and line variation while writing.
    • TheQuillDeal 15 Apr 18:58
      lamarax, thank you for a well-informed response! I've been worried that FountainPenHospital in NYC would suffer...
    • bhavini 15 Apr 18:28
      What's a relatively cheap tool for a newbie to use to try out new inks, without inking up a pen? I've a bunch of ink samples on their way but I just want to play around with them before I decide on which ones I want to buy more of for writing. I've never used anything except a fountain pen to write with ink before.
    • Penguincollector 15 Apr 17:03
      Hello @Jeffrey Sher, pen club information can be found in the Pen Clubs, Meetings, and Events sub forum. If you use Google site search you can find information specific to Israel.
    • Jeffrey Sher 14 Apr 8:25
      Shalom just joined . I have been collection fountain pens for many years. I believe there is a club in Israel that meets monthly. please let me have details. .
    • lamarax 11 Apr 0:58
      It's gonna end where 1929 left us: a world war, shambles, and 'growth by rebuilding'. That's the conservative view of cycling history --and the big plan. Even if our generations perish.
    • lamarax 11 Apr 0:49
      Of course trade wars are much, more important than the prices of consumer products. The true intention is to weaken the dollar, so that the Chinese start selling their US held debt. But the dollar being the defacto world reserve currency, it doesn't lose value that easily. So the idea is to target trade through artificially raising prices. Problem is, inflation will skyrocket. Good luck with that.
    • lamarax 11 Apr 0:33
      Guess who loses
    • lamarax 11 Apr 0:30
      In Europe, the only (truly) American produced brand is Esterbrook AFAIK. Tariffs will make Esterbrook products compete on the same level as some high-end European brands (let's say Aurora), while clearly the product is manufactured to compete on a much lower price level.
    • lamarax 11 Apr 0:24
      So let's say you want to buy a Montblanc or whatever. You pay the current tariff on top of the usual price, unless your local distributor is willing to absorb (some) of the difference
    • lamarax 11 Apr 0:20
      Tariffs are paid by the importer, not the exporter.
    • TheQuillDeal 10 Apr 2:44
      Can anyone explain how the tariff war will affect fountain pen prices??
    • Penguincollector 30 Mar 15:07
      Oh yes, pictures are on the “ I got this pen today” thread.
    • lectraplayer 29 Mar 9:19
      Is it here yet?
    • Penguincollector 26 Mar 5:00
      I just got the tracking information for my Starwalker💃🏻
    • T.D. Rabbit 3 Mar 12:46
      @lamarax I am horrified... And slightly intrigued. But mostly just scared.
    • lamarax 2 Mar 20:38
      Oh well. In case of failure you can always wring the paper to have a nice -albeit somewhat stale- cup of coffee back.
    • T.D. Rabbit 2 Mar 10:20
      @Astronymus I could use cornstarch... Or i could distill it and make it very concentrated.
    • T.D. Rabbit 2 Mar 10:20
      @lamarax That's what I used! (In reply to black coffee).. But the milk might not be good at all for paper.
    • Grayfeather 2 Mar 0:08
      Good day, all.
    • Gertrude F 20 Feb 17:58
      Sorry think I posted this in the wrong place. Used to be a user, just re-upped. Be kind. 😑
    • Gertrude F 20 Feb 17:56
      Looking to sell huge lot of pretty much every Man 200 made - FP, BP, MP, one or two RBs. Does anyone have a suggestion for a bulk purhase house? Thanks - and hope this doesn't violate any rules.
    • lamarax 17 Feb 18:05
      Cappuccino should work. Frothy milk also helps to lubricate the nib. But it has to be made by a barista.
    • Astronymus 17 Feb 16:19
      YOu might need to thicken the coffee with something. I admit I have no idea with what. But I'm pretty sure it would work.
    • asnailmailer 3 Feb 17:35
      it is incowrimo time and only very few people are tempting me
    • lamarax 31 Jan 21:34
      Try black coffee. No sugar.
    • T.D. Rabbit 31 Jan 8:11
      Coffee is too light to write with though I've tried.
    • Astronymus 29 Jan 21:46
      You can use coffee and all other kinds of fluid with a glas pen. 😉
    • Roger Zhao 29 Jan 14:37
      chocolate is yummy
    • Bucefalo 17 Jan 9:59
      anyone sells vacumatic push button shafts
    • stxrling 13 Jan 1:25
      Are there any threads or posts up yet about the California Pen Show in February, does anyone know?
    • lamarax 10 Jan 20:27
      Putting coffee in a fountain pen is far more dangerous
    • asnailmailer 9 Jan 0:09
      Don't drink the ink
    • zug zug 8 Jan 16:48
      Coffee inks or coffee, the drink? Both are yummy though.
    • LandyVlad 8 Jan 5:37
      I hear the price of coffee is going up. WHich is bad because I like coffee.
    • asnailmailer 6 Jan 14:43
      time for a nice cup of tea
    • Just J 25 Dec 1:57
      @liauyat re editing profile: At forum page top, find the Search panel. Just above that you should see your user name with a tiny down arrow [🔽] alongside. Click that & scroll down to CONTENT, & under that, Profile. Click that, & edit 'til thy heart's content!
    • liapuyat 12 Dec 12:20
      I can't seem to edit my profile, which is years out of date, because I've only returned to FPN again recently. How do you fix it?
    • mattaw 5 Dec 14:25
      @lantanagal did you do anything to fix that? I get that page every time I try to go to edit my profile...
    • Penguincollector 30 Nov 19:14
      Super excited to go check out the PDX Pen Bazaar today. I volunteered to help set up tables. It should be super fun, followed by Xmas tree shopping. 😁
    • niuben 30 Nov 10:41
      @Nurse Ratchet
    • Nurse Ratchet 30 Nov 2:49
      Newbie here!!! Helloall
    • Emes 25 Nov 23:31
      jew
    • Misfit 9 Nov 2:38
      lantanagal, I’ve only seen that happen when you put someone on the ignore list. I doubt a friend would do that.
    • lantanagal 7 Nov 19:01
      UPDATE - FIXED NOW Exact message is: Requested page not available! Dear Visitor of the Fountain Pen Nuthouse The page you are requesting to visit is not available to you. You are not authorised to access the requested page. Regards, The FPN Admin Team November 7, 2024
    • lantanagal 7 Nov 18:59
      UPDATE - FIXED NOW Trying to send a pen friend a reply to a message, keep getting an error message to say I don't have access. Anyone any ideas? (tried logging our and back in to no avail)
    • Dr.R 2 Nov 16:58
      Raina’s
    • fireant 2 Nov 1:36
      Fine-have you had a nibmeister look at it?
    • carlos.q 29 Oct 15:19
      @FineFinerFinest: have you seen this thread? https://www.fountainpennetwor...nging-pelikan-nibs/#comments
    • FineFinerFinest 24 Oct 8:52
      No replies required to my complaints about the Pelikan. A friend came to the rescue with some very magnification equipment - with the images thrown to a latge high res screen. Technology is a wonderful thing. Thanks to Mercian for the reply. I had been using the same paper & ink for sometime when the "singing" started. I have a theory but no proof that nibs get damaged when capping the pen. 👍
    • Mercian 22 Oct 22:28
      @FineFinerFinest: sometimes nib-'singing' can be lessened - or even cured - by changing the ink that one is putting through the pen, or the paper that one is using. N.b. *sometimes*. Good luck
    • Bluetaco 22 Oct 22:04
      howdy
    • FineFinerFinest 21 Oct 5:23
      I'm not expecting any replies to my question about the singing Pelikan nib. It seems, from reading the background, that I am not alone. It's a nice pen. It's such a pity Pelikan can't make decent nibs. I have occasionally met users who tell me how wonderful their Pelikan nib is. I've spent enough money to know that not everyone has this experience. I've worked on nibs occasionally over forty years with great success. This one has me beaten. I won't be buying any more Pelikan pens. 👎
    • FineFinerFinest 21 Oct 4:27
      I've had a Pelikan M805 for a couple of years now and cannot get the nib to write without singing. I've worked on dozens of nibs with great success. Ny suggestion about what's going wrong? 😑
    • Bhakt 12 Oct 5:45
      Any feedback in 100th anniversary Mont Blanc green pens?
    • Glens pens 8 Oct 15:08
      @jordierocks94 i happen to have platinum preppy that has wrote like (bleep) since i bought it my second pen....is that something you would wish to practice on?
    • jordierocks94 4 Oct 6:26
      Hello all - New here. My Art studies have spilled me into the ft pen world where I am happily submerged and floating! I'm looking to repair some cheap pens that are starving for ink yet filled, and eventually get new nibs; and development of repair skills (an even longer learning curve than my art studies - lol). Every hobby needs a hobby, eh ...
    • The_Beginner 18 Sept 23:35
      horse notebooks if you search the title should still appear though it wont show you in your proflie
    • Jayme Brener 16 Sept 22:21
      Hi, guys. I wonder if somebody knows who manufactured the Coro fountain pens.
    • TheHorseNotebooks 16 Sept 13:11
      Hello, it's been ages for me since I was here last time. I had a post (http://www.fountainpennetwork...-notebooks/?view=getnewpost) but I see that it is no longer accessible. Is there anyway to retrieve that one?
    • Refujio Rodriguez 16 Sept 5:39
      I have a match stick simplomatic with a weidlich nib. Does anyone know anything about this pen?
    • The_Beginner 15 Sept 16:11
      dusty yes, glen welcome
    • Glens pens 11 Sept 1:22
      Hello, Im new to FPN I'm so happy to find other foutain penattics. collecting almost one year ,thought I would say hello to everyone.
    • DustyBin 8 Sept 14:34
      I haven't been here for ages... do I take it that private sales are no longer allowed? Also used to be a great place to sell and buy some great pens
    • Sailor Kenshin 1 Sept 12:37
      Lol…
    • JungleJim 1 Sept 1:55
      Perhaps it's like saying Beetlejuice 3 times to get that person to appear, though with @Sailor Kenshin you only have to say it twice?
    • Sailor Kenshin 31 Aug 21:06
      ?
    • Duffy 29 Aug 19:31
      @Sailor Kenshin @Sailor Kenshin
    • Seney724 26 Aug 22:07
    • Diablo 26 Aug 22:05
      Thank you so much, Seney724. I really appreciate your help!
    • Seney724 26 Aug 21:43
      I have no ties or relationship. Just a very happy customer. He is a very experienced Montblanc expert.
    • Seney724 26 Aug 21:42
      I strongly recommend Kirk Speer at https://www.penrealm.com/
    • Diablo 26 Aug 21:35
      @Seney724. The pen was recently disassembled and cleaned, but the nib and feed were not properly inserted into the holder. I'm in Maryland.
    • Diablo 26 Aug 21:32
      @Seney724. The nib section needs to be adjusted properly.
    • Seney724 26 Aug 18:16
      @Diablo. Where are you? What does it need?
    • Diablo 26 Aug 16:58
      Seeking EXPERIENCED, REPUTABLE service/repair for my 149. PLEASE help!!!
    • Penguincollector 19 Aug 19:42
      @Marta Val, reach out to @terim, who runs Peyton Street Pens and is very knowledgeable about Sheaffer pens
    • Marta Val 19 Aug 14:35
      Hello, could someone recommend a reliable venue: on line or brick and mortar in Fairfax, VA or Long Island, NY to purchase the soft parts and a converter to restore my dad's Sheaffer Legacy? please. Thanks a mill.
    • The_Beginner 18 Aug 2:49
      is there a guy who we can message to find a part for us with a given timelimit if so please let me know his name!
    • virtuoso 16 Aug 15:15
      what happene to the new Shaeffer inks?
    • Scribs 14 Aug 17:09
      fatehbajwa, in Writing Instruments, "Fountain Pens + Dip Pens First Stop" ?
    • fatehbajwa 14 Aug 12:17
      Back to FPN after 14 years. First thing I noticed is that I could not see a FS forum. What has changed? 🤔
    • Kika 5 Aug 10:22
      Are there any fountain pen collectors in Qatar?
    • T.D. Rabbit 31 July 18:58
      Ahh okay, thanks!
    • Scribs 29 July 18:51
      @ TDRabbit, even better would be in Creative Expressions area, subform The Write Stuff
    • T.D. Rabbit 29 July 11:40
      Okay, thanks!
    • JungleJim 29 July 0:46
      @T.D. Rabbit Try posting it in the "Chatter Forum". You have to be logged in to see it.
    • T.D. Rabbit 28 July 17:54
      Hello! Is there a thread anywhere 'round here where one can post self-composed poetry? If not, would it be alright if I made one? I searched on google, but to no avail...
    • OldFatDog 26 July 19:41
      I have several Parker Roller Ball & Fiber Tip refills in the original packaging. Where and how do I sell them? The couple that I've opened the ink still flowed when put to paper. Also if a pen would take the foller ball refill then it should take the fiber tip as well? Anyway it's been awhile and I'm want to take my message collection beyond the few pieces that I have... Meaning I don't have a Parker these refills will fit in 🙄
    • RegDiggins 23 July 12:40
      Recently was lucky enough to buy a pristine example of the CF crocodile ball with the gold plating. Then of course I faced the same problem we all have over the years ,of trying to find e refill. Fortunately I discovered one here in the U.K. I wonder if there are other sources which exist in other countries, by the way they were not cheap pen
    • The_Beginner 20 July 20:35
      Hows it going guys i have a code from pen chalet that i wont use for 10% off and it ends aug 31st RC10AUG its 10% off have at it fellas
    • T.D. Rabbit 19 July 9:33
      Somewhat confusing and off-putting ones, as said to me by my very honest friends. I don't have an X account though :<
    • piano 19 July 8:41
      @The Devil Rabbit what kind of? Let’s go to X (twitter) with #inkdoodle #inkdoodleFP
    • Mort639 17 July 1:03
      I have a Conway Stewart Trafalgar set. It was previously owned by actor Russell Crowe and includes a letter from him. Can anyone help me with assessing its value?
    • Sailor Kenshin 15 July 17:41
      There must be a couple of places here to share artworks.
    • T.D. Rabbit 15 July 12:45
      Hullo! I really like making ink doodles, and I'd like to share a few. Anywhere on the site I can do so? Thanks in advance!
    • Sailor Kenshin 6 July 17:58
      Pay It Forward.
    • AndWhoDisguisedAs 6 July 16:59
      where would I post wanting to trade bottle of ink straight up?
    • JungleJim 3 July 16:14
      @Bill Wood-- just look at the message below you that was posted by @PAKMAN. He is a moderator here on the forums.
    Load More
  • Files






×
×
  • Create New...