Ten Notebook Bleed-Through Battle

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

SCORECARD



Round X Standings:

1. Clairefontaine - 0.5

2. Maruman Mnemosyne - 1.5

3. Rhodia 80gsm - 2.5

4. Staples Sustainable Earth - 4.0

5. Cambridge - 4.5

T6. Black n' Red (Poland) - 8.0

T6. Five Star Heavyweight - 8.0

8. Black n' Red (Germany) - 8.5

9. Hilroy - 10.0

10. Staples Notes - 16.5

Overall Standings:

1. Clairefontaine - 15.0

2. Maruman Mnemosyne - 21.0

3. Cambridge - 33.0

4. Rhodia 80gsm - 34.0

5. Staples Sustainable Earth - 36.0

6. Black n' Red (Germany) - 48.0

7. Black n' Red (Poland) - 77.0

T8. Five Star Heavyweight - 92.5

T8. Hilroy - 92.5

10. Staples Notes - 167.5

Cumulative Bleed-Through Score By Sample:

Sample 91 - 1.5

Sample 92 - 4.5

Sample 93 - 6.5

Sample 94 - 8.0

Sample 95 - 11.5

Sample 96 - 7.0

Sample 97 - 7.0

Sample 98 - 5.0

Sample 99 - 3.0

Sample 100 - 10.0

Edited October 21, 2016 by jaysongo

[TSherbs]

this is such an excellent thread

 

thank you!

[jaysongo]

this is such an excellent thread

 

thank you!

 

Thanks, I'm glad you enjoy it. I'll try to post them more frequently.

[bob_hayden]

jaysongo, is your data available in electronic form in a spreadsheet or database? Though your intent was to test papers, I think you equally have data on a wide variety of pens and inks. That could easily be harvested from an electronic file, perhaps much less easily from hand written notes.

[jaysongo]

jaysongo, is your data available in electronic form in a spreadsheet or database? Though your intent was to test papers, I think you equally have data on a wide variety of pens and inks. That could easily be harvested from an electronic file, perhaps much less easily from hand written notes.

 

I do have a spreadsheet that I use, and I'll make it available if you're still interested in it, but I don't list pens and ink at all as I only use it for tabulation, so it's only referenced by sample number.

[bob_hayden]

Thanks. It looks like the information could be added to the file based on the scans above, but, given the (lack of) speed and accuracy of my typing, I never volunteer for data entry!-)

[ItwasLuck]

Wow thanks for the amazing comparisons and those amazing scans! Definitely love my current PPI= Visconti Kakadu w/ M 18K + Mnemosyne N195 + KWZ Dark Brown, it's so heavenly smooth! Even prefer it to my Seven Seas notebook atm. Gonna try out some Tsubame though, want to see what a little more texture feels like!

[jaysongo]

Wow thanks for the amazing comparisons and those amazing scans! Definitely love my current PPI= Visconti Kakadu w/ M 18K + Mnemosyne N195 + KWZ Dark Brown, it's so heavenly smooth! Even prefer it to my Seven Seas notebook atm. Gonna try out some Tsubame though, want to see what a little more texture feels like!

Thanks for the nice words. I've never used a Visconti, always wanted to though. Never paid more than $100 CAD for a pen, for that matter. One of these days I'll break that rule...

 

I'll probably have another round out tomorrow or the day after.

[jaysongo]

Thanks. It looks like the information could be added to the file based on the scans above, but, given the (lack of) speed and accuracy of my typing, I never volunteer for data entry!-)

The link to the file you requested: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/s/sj4krdys40s0x5f/000Score%20Card.xlsx

[jaysongo]

ROUND XI

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]

[jaysongo]