Pilot Elite Crosshatch Pocket Pen Review

[Flounder]

Introduction
Here’s my first Japanese ‘pocket pen’, or ‘long-short’ pen. It’s a 1976 Pilot Elite, in a half-crosshatch finish I’ve sometimes seen christened the ‘Isaac Newton’. We’ve been acquainted for about 4 months now.

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20A6.jpg


Pocket pens are one area where the big Japanese manufacturers really allowed themselves to get inventive with their designs, and create something authentically Japanese rather than a Japanese reflection of Western pens. When I realised that a quality vintage pocket pen could be obtained by bypassing eBay, I became very enthused by the idea of picking up something representative of the genre!

If you’re as unfamiliar with the type as I, Bruno Taut’s resource at Crónicas Estilográficas is a mine of fascinating information and photographs of Japanese pocket pens (don’t get lost following all the amazing posts, come back and finish the review sometime!).

Appearance & Design
The aesthetic of this particular Pilot Elite is decidedly masculine, but in a classy, stylish way more self-possessed than that of the all-metal, exposed bolts (even bolt action) me-macho cottage industry pens currently in vogue.

‘Debonair ‘ is probably the word I’m looking for, because this is one of very few inanimate objects I think of as having bone fide charm. Looking down at the enamelled steel crosshatch design of its unusually long cap over a short black barrel, it’s easy to anthropomorphise the Elite as a dapper gent in a windowpane-patterned coat.

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20overview.jpg

 

During my browse of pens available, I found it curious how few masculine or even gender-neutral designs seem to be around. In contrast, there’s a very good selection of overtly feminine Japanese pocket pens! To my uncouth eye at least, their colours, finishes, fat swoopy faux cap bands and floral decorations are quite reminiscent of lipsticks. This is not a criticism, only rather a surprise, given their origin story as pens to fit in the shirt pocket of conservative 1960’s Japanese salary men. Is there a missing chapter?

Anyway, back to the appearance of this specific Pilot Elite. The rhodiated 18 karat gold nib understates the pen’s worth, and complements the Elite’s unaffected chrome plated clip & section ring well. In a world where so many steel nibs are emblazoned with decorative tildes and gold plated to affect costliness, I appreciate that Pilot had the daring not to flaunt where the money’s been spent!

The semi-hooded nib design sported by this Elite arguably strikes the best balance between appearance and practicality. This Elite differs from others of the same name that are fitted with the ‘inset’ nib type. Here, the tab-clamped nib is semi hooded for practicality. There are no sealant-reliant joints through which ink can wick to your fingers (I had enough of tending to that kind of quirk with my Targas). Reading through the experiences of Hari et al. (1,2,3) prior to purchase, I figured I’d be happier in avoiding the inset nib Elites, sidestepping any future hassles. For similar reasons, I decided against another Pilot pocket pen I was considering, the conventially-nibbed Volex. The Volex has metal trim rings abutting the nib; while these look purposeful, too many examples had suffered corrosion owing to ink exposure.

The overall look and certain design elements are reminiscent of the Parker 65; in particular, the vestigial hood and clip on nib. Both are improved upon in ways that make me think the Elite’s designers cast an eye over Parker’s 1967 effort; the hood plastic is much thicker, shorter, and shaped in a less fragile wave rather than an acute point. The nib geometry is far less complex compared to the 65’s myriad of folds and curves, and the feed certainly looks easier to nib-set than the 65’s thick wedge of nightmare (the service manual for which warns against separating from the nib)!

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20Parker%2065%20open%20comparison.jpg

 

Inevitably for a pocket pen, a lot of effort has gone into the cap’s functionality. The clip is spring mounted, and the section ring doubles as a stop for the slip cap, after the fashion of Parker’s 45. I like this feature, it means the cap can never be jammed on, or the inner cap split from excess stress.

Due to the unusually long section, the cap’s steel clutch fingers engage with the most cylindrical portion of the section through over an inch of travel, making it quite secure by the time it reaches the section ring stop. As well as lending a high quality look, the depth of the cap engraving gives excellent tactile purchase for sliding the slip cap off and on - capping and posting being a strictly two hand exercise.

Construction & Quality
As a major feature of this pen style’s design, the elongated cap is well made inside and out. In particular, the cap crosshatching and enamelling is really superb – just look at depth of impression the crosshatching makes in a blob of Rodico putty. The rough troughs visible in the macro detail must lend an excellent key to the enamel, none of which shows any sign whatever of chipping away in the last 40 years.

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20cap%20detail.jpg

 

I wish I knew more about how the cap was put together, because it looks a high quality item! Peering inside, there's the inner cap you'd expect, and it's nice to see that the steel cap clutch has 5 fingers, which reduces their individual load and helps keep the cap concentric to the barrel. The bevelled clip is usefully spring mounted, as previously mentioned. This one is in pretty fresh condition - from the listings I've seen, the clip’s plating seems to be this model’s weak spot.

The cartridge piercing tube is plastic rather than steel, as with other Pilot cartridge pens I've seen. It also has a split in the middle, which seems to fulfil the same function as the later Pilot 78G’s molded cartridge piercer ink flow channels. Part of me wishes the piercer was made of steel, but I have no basis to denigrate the longevity of Pilot's plastic piercer design.

 

As seems to be common with many Pilot pocket pens, the coupler screwed right out of the section, so I secured it with a thin smear of especially weak rosin sealant.

Exterior plastics were tired throughout, with many microscratches. Most polished out, but not quickly or easily. This, together with the fact that I’ve not seen any photos or read any reports of warped vintage pocket pens, hopefully means that strong, high quality plastics were used to manufacture the Elite.

Overall, fit and finish are excellent: Little details jump out at you, such as the cap being perfectly concentric to the stop ring, or the split between tines and oblong breather hole being perfectly centred. There is a slight gap between the nib and ‘hood’, but I’m not sure if this is intentional or perhaps has some function – I’ve seen the same in many photos of this pen.

Weight & Dimensions
As is probably fitting for a pocket pen, it is ideal for concealed carry, being diminutive and light enough not to alter the drape of even the cheapest, flimsiest high summer linen. With the current ink cartridge over halfway spent, the Elite weighs 16 grams, the cap contributing 9.

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20Parker%20Jotter%20closed%20comparison.jpg

 

 

The Elite really executes the ‘long-short’ format well. Capped, it is shorter (11.8cm) than a standard Parker Jotter ballpoint, and posted, longer (14.8cm). The posted length is excellent, and the semi-hooded design and elongated section will allow a very relaxed, spread-fingered grip. The section thickness is on a par with the Parker 61’s.

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20Parker%20Jotter%20open%20comparison.jpg

 

Unposted, I’ve found the Elite is fine for jotting down a phone number, email address or even a brief note (at the laconic extreme of brevity). For heavy writing sessions, I have noticed that the section can get a little slippery after writing at speed for 1.5 hours in a hot room.


Nib & Performance
18 karat gold, rhodium plated. The nib is very appealing!

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20nib%20detail.jpg

 

The shape of the nib gives a strong sense of accuracy, a sort of visual allusion to a long, tapered arrow. In isolation, you can see it’s in fact quite short! The oblong breather hole and slender delta tine sweep help create this clever effect. The continuity of the mildly tapering section and ‘long’ nib give an agreeable sensation of precision control akin to writing with a recently sharpened pencil.

The cap encourages a fairly low angle grip, which I prefer anyway. On first receipt, the fine nib was slightly too feedback-y on certain strokes, but responded well to slight micromesh polishing. Aside from that minor inconvenience – to be expected after 40 years of a stranger’s handwriting in a foreign script – the nib had no other issues. The tines were still well aligned, testament to a light hand in previous use.

Confounding the usual fountain pen caveats, this Elite has the most remarkable dry out resistance when left uncapped. Using standard Pilot blue cartridges, the pen boasts instant start up on a 90gsm Oxford Campus pad, after 25 minutes left lying uncapped. This is phenomenal, I’ve no idea how Pilot achieved it. For all I know, it could last longer than the 25 minutes I’ve (repeatedly) tested for.

The 18k nib is quite soft, and writes an even line of decent wetness using Pilot blue. Being a Japanese fine, it’s versatile, capable of writing a composed line even on cheap, absorptive paper.

Filling System & Maintenance
The proprietary Pilot cartridges the Elite uses are among my favourites. Their mouths are wider than their ends, and Parker-style channels are molded into the whole length of the walls to ensure ink flows downward rather than beads away from the feed.

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20capilary%20detail.jpg

 

To fit the Elite’s pocket pen profile, the cartridge meets it piercer especially deep within the section. This obscures much of the cartridge, making the ink level difficult to judge. Perhaps in recognition of this drawback, the feed is translucent to help warn when the ink is nearly emptied.

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20carts%20and%20converters.jpg

 

I think it’s commendable this diminutive pen uses standard size carts with no further penalties - I’m assuming there must be a commensurate reduction in the feed’s buffering capacity, but haven’t experienced any flow issues at all.
For bottled inks, the Elite will also accept certain converters from Pilot’s range. On the FPN forum, Butangmucat has reported the new con-40 fits his Elite; I’ve picked up a con20 squeeze converter before they’re discontinued.

Half the reason I went with a Pilot pocket pen rather than less expensive but very similar looking models by other manufacturers was how impressed I’ve been with the quality of Pilot’s cartridges, ink, and converter availability. To get the pen working again mostly required only a soaking and flushing to remove the majority of dried up old ink, then a short spell in the ultrasonic cleaner. The nib required a little smoothing but not much. Fairly uneventful!

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20servicing.jpg

Cost & Value
Begad, here comes a strong opinion! Grin and nod along till the ghastly thing blows away to bother someone else!

For Western enthusiasts, I’ve noticed that vintage Pilot pocket pens offered on eBay and forums like FPN are dear, at a distasteful markup of 100-200% over the Japanese going rate.

This used to be confined to the Pilot Myu, but now the more conventional Elite and even plain steel Volex are being listed – used - at unseemly asking prices up to and comfortably exceeding the price of a brand new Elite 95S. This includes obviously flawed examples with unsecured section-barrel couplers, corroded Volex nib rings, and dried up old carts still installed, indicative of neglect.

I ask you, is that playing the game? Eschewing the robber barons, I paid slightly less than I usually would for an unrestored domestic Parker 51 (including shipping charges etc.).

In the condition my Elite turned up in, and having the tools & supplies to hand to service the pen, I think it was very good value; I’ve no buyer remorse. Had I paid twice as much, or had it suffered damage in the simple bubblewrap envelope it was transported in, my ability to appreciate its many charms would be a little more tempered.

Conclusion
I realise a lot of this review reads like a mash note! Well, there you have it; I’m very taken with the Pilot Elite. Certainly, there’s plenty that can go wrong with you’ve no knowledge about the model you’re interested in, when you remove eBay buyer protection from the equation, and when you add useless machine translation to cross-planet shipping. In this happy case, Tyche nodded her approval and the whole show ran without a hitch.

 

This is a great fountain pen!

 

http://i773.photobucket.com/albums/yy19/flounder2009/Pilot%20Elite%20Isaac%20Newton/Pilot%20Elite%20pangrams.jpg

 

Ps – Archaeology buffs, for a slice of living morphological typology, compare the form and function of this 40 year old Elite with the appropriately named Pilot Timeline range of today!

Edited April 6, 2016 by Flounder

[sannidh]

Thank you for sharing such a detailed (including the putty impression ) and wonderful review of the Ancient Elite

[jay.is.here]

Nice review.

[utopic]

Good looking pen and very nice review

[hari317]

Nice review of a favorite line of pens. The design is a time tested one and th nib on Flounder's pen continues to be produced by Pilot and nowadays comes installed in their Desk pen DP500 (click image for review)

http://i1313.photobucket.com/albums/t543/hari_317/PilotDeskPens/IMG_8793.jpg

[Tas]

So thorough, thank you !

 

I've always been tempted by one of these. But as I've given up buying pens . . .

[garyc]

I enjoyed reading this review, very well written if I may say, thanks.

 

A few questions: if you are not in the habit of posting, as I am (with one exception, the Prera, which I haven't been using much of late), is it much of a fag to keep having to do it, as I presume the pen isn't really useable without? However, the drying out resistance would be a very useful feature to use as a pen, say, to annotate a document as you read it and would minimise the posting/unposting ritual.

 

Would it be too impolite to ask you where you bought it from and how much you paid for it? On eBay, there is a BIN offer right now for a similar model (though fully cross-hatched, which perhaps makes it a more premium/rare model) for $180 which does seem a bit steep.

 

Interesting what you say about the inset nib versions. I have a Carene which developed some capillary induced seepage and it's very annoying.

[mehandiratta]

thank you for the review....

[rollerboy]

Great review ... which will unfortunately inspire more people to go looking for one of these making it that much more difficult for me to find one!

[Flounder]

Thanks for the encouragement everybody!

 

 

  On 4/6/2016 at 9:37 AM, hari317 said:

Nice review of a favorite line of pens. The design is a time tested one and th nib on Flounder's pen continues to be produced by Pilot and nowadays comes installed in their Desk pen DP500 (click image for review)

 

Very interesting Hari, I was completely unware of these. Comparing my Elite to the photos of your modern DP500, it looks like the nib, feed, and even the whole DP500 section could be donor candidates should the Elite ever meet with an accident - thank you very much for bringing these to my attention!!

 

 

  On 4/7/2016 at 5:59 AM, garyc said:

I enjoyed reading this review, very well written if I may say, thanks.

A few questions: if you are not in the habit of posting, as I am (with one exception, the Prera, which I haven't been using much of late), is it much of a fag to keep having to do it, as I presume the pen isn't really useable without? However, the drying out resistance would be a very useful feature to use as a pen, say, to annotate a document as you read it and would minimise the posting/unposting ritual.

Would it be too impolite to ask you where you bought it from and how much you paid for it? On eBay, there is a BIN offer right now for a similar model (though fully cross-hatched, which perhaps makes it a more premium/rare model) for $180 which does seem a bit steep.

Interesting what you say about the inset nib versions. I have a Carene which developed some capillary induced seepage and it's very annoying.

 

Hi gary, the posting question I asked myself before buying, as I'm not in the habit of posting either. Furthermore, I've found the format introduces an extra step in the posting process that a conventional pen doesn't require. In the first week or so, I went through this pattern:

 

1. The fingers of my left hand holds the long cap, the fingers of my right hold the mini barrel. I pull them apart.
2. I post the cap on the barrel - oh wait, the barrel is so short that the fingers of my right hand are in the way.
3. Walk my right hand fingers up to the section so that the cap can take up all the barrel space.
4. Post the cap.

After the first week, my fingers got much more adept at posting nimbly. It's not a thought process any more, more natural muscle memory; now I hold the barrel between thumb and forefinger when pulling the cap off, then pivot the pen 180 degrees with my third finger. Somehow my thumb and forefinger end up on the section side of the clutch ring, and the barrel is clear, ready for the cap. Posting takes place within 3 seconds or so, capping about a 1-2, without rushing myself.

 

I suppose my answer is "Posting a pocket pen is mostly compulsory, I got used to posting it, but you might not!". It is true that the dry out resistance is very convenient and in use, I don't find myself capping the pen for the nib's sake the same way I do others.

 

Ooh, price and source. Rollerboy's comment illustrates why I was reluctant to divulge, because IMO we're a bit daft "to go looking for one of these" [emphasis added] as if it's something so amazing & unheard of we need to throw bundles of currency notes at the first one we see. Let's say I bought from a seller in Japan, and the price of the pen alone was 3810 yen (less than £25).These are modern pens of conventional manufacture and nothing especially rare.

 

It's a shame that the price of truly quirky, interestingly made pocket pens like the striped Myu has risen to the levels it has, but that's how it is - there's simply nothing quite like it out there. If I was looking at the $180 double-crosshatch Elite you mention however, I would think long and hard about what kind of premium I'd be willing to pay over a brand new $80 95S...

Edited April 9, 2016 by Flounder

[garyc]

Posting: Blimey, what a palaver!

 

You don't work in ISO 9001 quality do you? You description sounds like a "Posting the cap" process definition or work instruction. You probably just need a flow chart to complete it :-) Not sure I could be done with that, but at least the dry-out resistance minimises the frequency that you have to do it.

 

Now it has to be said the price you paid is pretty good for an 18k gold nib pen, despite its foibles. You are probably right to keep mum to try and maintain some sanity in pricing.

[Flounder]

I think I could have been more articulate regarding your posting question.

The fundamental question was left unanswered. IS it much of a fag to keep having to do it?
 
Especially for you, I carried out a 4 minute experiment to investigate just that, set to the theme tune of that classic family sitcom, "Too Many Cooks". What will come first, RSI or insanity?

 

 

Edited April 10, 2016 by Flounder

[utopic]

I just had to give that video a thumbs up

[garyc]

Ha ha, I think you've proved your point. Above and beyond - love it! :-)

[tennessee]

What a fantastic review!! I have many of these, all NOS..... I just received quite an education.

 

Thank you so much------ what a pen!

[Gloucesterman]

  On 4/10/2016 at 12:27 PM, Flounder said:

 

I think I could have been more articulate regarding your posting question.

The fundamental question was left unanswered. IS it much of a fag to keep having to do it?

 

Especially for you, I carried out a 4 minute experiment to investigate just that, set to the theme tune of that classic family sitcom, "Too Many Cooks". What will come first, RSI or insanity?

 

 

 

Re: the video..."Looks like deja vu all over again" - Yogi Berra.

Excellent review with nice insights.

 

It really becomes a problem when someone finds a nice pen, shares the information and then everyone starts the hunt and bidding war to get the particular pen.

 

I just got two of these "pocket pens". One is a new 95S Elite w/ a fine nib. The second is an older one with almost a hooded nib w/ an EF nib. The older one is quite slender compared to the newer one. Both have 14k nibs I was told. I may end up selling the older one if I find it too small for my hand. The modern one is delightful and I may keep a look out for similar pens in the future. Who knows I may have some luck and find one at a reasonable price!

 

I have just about given up expecting to find an MYU that I can afford.

 

Thank you again for an excellent review... :thumbup: :thumbup:

Edited July 17, 2016 by brgmarketing

[Flounder]

Ta for the kind words folks

 

Thankfully, the only Myu I would be interested in is the striped version. I say thankfully because it will never trouble my wallet at the super-heated premium it commands!

 

The plain steel Myu is a little too austere for my tastes, especially for a steel nibbed pen with such a galling price. I feel I've been there before with the Hero 849, 850 and Parker falcon, writing-experience wise.

 

How are you finding the compulsory-posting on the 95S, brg?